Some of you might not have seen this seminal work of pulp critique and those who have might appreciate some vintage goods.

It’s hard to overstate the feeling of catharsis I got from finding this review after hours of fruitlessly hoping for EY to give me another chapter of scientific method being applied on Potterian magic and instead getting dozens of chapters of Enders Game fanfic I don’t understand, Aristotelian science style asspulls, Yudkowsky’s headfanon that made Rowling’s worldbuilding look meticulously consistent, and partial transfiguration being abused to an extent rivaling the application of healing magic in Redo of the Healer with only somewhat more progressive gender politics.