• roboRoboat@lemmy.world
    link
    fedilink
    English
    arrow-up
    1
    ·
    1 year ago

    Thanks for the insight! I’ve learned a little more about Toyota’s process specifically in this thread, which is cool.

    I would argue that “over engineer” in my original context is more in the sense that aircraft are “over engineered” to be reliable beyond normal operating parameters. American cars at the time were generally built with like 100k miles in mind before needing a rebuild. Then Toyota comes rolling in with engines that can do 3-4 times that no prob. So Toyotas are “over engineered” in the sense that “these engines go above and beyond what other manufacturers consider acceptable.”

    But I agree that there’s maybe some better terminology to be used because when I think of “over engineered” in context of cars, I am mostly thinking of things like, “Okay, I get that maybe you eek out a teeny bit more efficiency, but putting the water pump under the manifold where it can leak into the block seems like a really bad idea.” I’ve updated my comment to reflect that, open to suggestions haha.

    • Margot Robbie@lemmy.world
      link
      fedilink
      English
      arrow-up
      0
      ·
      1 year ago

      I would really recommend reading Riker’s “The Toyota Way”, it’s short but excellent read, although a bit self-congratulatory at times about the success of NUMMI.

      When I think about the word “Over-engineered”, it usually refers to something like Juicero that adds unnecessary complexity to a problem solving approach, and good reliable engineering is the exact opposite of that. A minor example of that applied to a car engine is the turbocharger, it greatly enhances the efficiency of the fuel intake by forced convection, however the added complexity made it less reliable.

      And the other thing to note that is that aerospace products are less reliable by necessity as their Factor of Safety never really go past 1.2 due to weight requirements, whereas you typically want the Factor of Safety of a normal design to be in the 2-3 range.